Staff in Tauranga Hospital’s mental health unit have raised safety fears after attacks by patients high on P or synthetic cannabis.
Instead of hiring more security guards to help deal with violent patients, a letter and leaked emails show staff claim District Health Board management have asked them to calm aggressive patients by “talking them down”.
“The police have got riot gear and handcuffs and can’t control them. How are we expected to with words?”
In response, the DHB said most mental health patients were not violent. It conceded security guards were not routinely used for interventions but if a duress alarm was activated there was an immediate response from appropriately trained staff.
Figures from the Bay of Plenty Health Board show there have been 62 acts of aggression against staff at the Tauranga Mental Health Unit in 2017 that could include pushing.
The accusations, along with the leaked internal e-mails from staff to management at Tauranga Hospital, raised concerns about safety.
The e-mails were leaked after it was reported 200 patients had been locked in seclusion rooms in the psychiatric unit at Tauranga Hospital in the past three years one patient spent 173 hours and 53 minutes in a room.
The documents show incidences including staff being punched by patients and one being seriously injured “resulting in him only been able to work light duties for the past several months”.
“It’s distressing witnessing our valued staff members being attacked.”
An e-mail sent on March 5 to colleagues said ”over the past week in the mental health inpatient unit there has been further incidences of violence and aggression”.
Some of the incidents reported included a patient smashing a reinforced glass window, “causing fear and distress to patients, staff and students alike”.
”The patient was locked in the admission suite and repeatedly banged on the duty room window until it smashed.”
There was no discussion following the event, the email said and patients hid in their rooms.
“My colleagues and I went around that whole night in a state of shock.”‘
Another involved an aggressive, violent patient in a seclusion room where staff had to call security for assistance and support.
“We were advised security were unable to attend as there was only one security person on for the whole hospital and they were not allowed to leave the emergency department.”
An incident form was lodged and the writer said ”I find this situation highly unacceptable, this is the second time I have e-mailed management in regards to the health and safety of the staff in this unit.”
“The first time I e-mailed my concerns I received no reply.”
In a statement, mental health and addictions service business leader Eileen Hughes said the safety of staff was paramount and the DHB had a zero tolerance policy for physical or verbal violent conduct. Staff were trained for such situations and wore duress alarms.
“If a duress alarm is activated there is an immediate response with appropriately trained staff. Security staff are not routinely used for interventions in mental health.”
It was important to remember the majority of people who access inpatient mental health services were not violent and are more likely to have been victims of abuse, stigma and discrimination, she said.
“People under the influence of methamphetamine or other illicit substances can present with unpredictable behaviours and have an increased risk of aggressive tendencies. As with other areas of health, there is a need to ensure appropriate treatment is provided while maintaining staff safety.”
Ms Hughes said if an incident of aggression did occur, a debriefing was undertaken with staff and patients following the incident to address issues and offer support.
“If an assault has occurred our staff were supported to lay a complaint with the police and there was additional support available through the DHB and a national training programme for ‘Safe Practice Effective Communication’ currently being rolled out across New Zealand,” she said.
New Zealand Nurses’ Organisation Bay of Plenty organiser Angela Neil said there were issues around methamphetamine addicts being in the mental health unit.
“Tauranga is not alone and what I would say; is the mental health unit the right place for people on meth?. It’s a national problem. These units were developed for therapeutic intervention.
“They can’t do therapeutic intervention with someone high on meth.”
Nationally police attended on average 90 mental health related events every 24 hours.